The Navajo-Hopi land dispute: an American tragedy

Brugge, David M.

Book

The Navajo-Hopi land dispute: an American tragedy

University of New Mexico Press • Albuquerque • Published In 1994 • Pages:

By: Brugge, David M..

Abstract
This is a firsthand account of the Healing vs. Jones land dispute between the Hopi and Navajo. Brugge worked for the Navajo, researching archeaological sites, archives, and life histories for proof of Navajo land occupancy. The 1882 Executive Order Reservation set aside land within the Navajo Reservation for the Hopi. Disputes arose over encroachment by Navajo herds and Hopi expansion. Tensions came to a head when mineral and oil deposits were discovered. The Hopi lay claim to the subsurface rights, which the Navajo disputed. Proof of occupancy became a major argument in the court case. Brugge documents the trials and hearings, and the efforts to educated and inform people on the reservation. While the trial lawyers for the Hopi tried to draw a wedge between 'peace-loving' Hopi and the 'savage' Navajo, Brugge shows that the actual split was between traditional Hopi who supported the Navajo and a modern educated elite whose interests lay with White politicians and developers. Brugge was not privy to, nor did he research, the possible collusion between mining companies, state politicans, and Hopi leaders. His major concern and focus is the racist arguments of the lawyers.

Internal migration

Settlement patterns

Real property

Acquisition and relinquishment of property

HRAF PubDate

2004

Region